Sweet Sicily in the Big Apple: Finding the Best Cannolis in NYC

When it comes to desserts that are equal parts indulgent and iconic, few can rival the cannoli. This staple of Italian pastry has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of dessert lovers worldwide, and nowhere is its legacy more celebrated than in New York City. From the bustling streets of Little Italy to hidden gems in the Bronx, NYC is a paradise for those on the hunt for the perfect cannoli.

And what better way to celebrate your love for this classic treat than by sporting our “Keep Calm & Cannoli On” t-shirt? It’s the ultimate attire for any cannoli enthusiast embarking on a sweet adventure.

The Art of Cannoli Making

A traditional cannoli is a harmonious blend of crisp, fried pastry shells filled with rich, creamy ricotta, often garnished with chocolate chips, pistachios, or candied fruit. Originating in Sicily, this beloved dessert has a history as rich as its filling, dating back to the Arab rule in the 10th century.

Authentic cannoli are prized for their balance: the shell must be crisp and sturdy enough to hold the filling without becoming soggy, while the ricotta-based filling should be smooth, lightly sweetened, and perfectly creamy. Many bakeries in NYC remain loyal to traditional methods, ensuring every bite transports you straight to Sicily.

Best Cannoli Shops in NYC

If you’re ready to dive into the city’s finest cannoli offerings, here are five must-visit spots that deliver exceptional takes on this Italian classic.

1. Ferrara Bakery & Cafe – Little Italy

Ferrara, established in 1892, is a cornerstone of NYC’s Italian pastry scene. Their cannoli recipe has remained unchanged for over a century, featuring perfectly crisp shells and a velvety ricotta filling. The bustling ambiance of Little Italy adds to the charm, making it a quintessential stop for any cannoli lover.

2. Veniero’s Pasticceria & Cafe – East Village

Veniero’s is famous for offering cannoli in a range of sizes, from bite-sized minis to generously portioned classics. Their filling is known for its light and airy texture, making each bite a delight. Don’t miss their chocolate-dipped cannoli for an extra touch of decadence.

3. Pasticceria Rocco – West Village

This West Village staple is celebrated for its hand-filled cannolis, ensuring every order is fresh and delicious. The balance between the crisp shell and rich ricotta filling keeps locals and tourists coming back for more.

4. Villabate Alba – Bensonhurst, Brooklyn

Villabate Alba brings a taste of Sicily to Brooklyn. Their cannolis, made with authentic sheep’s milk ricotta, are a revelation. The dedication to Sicilian tradition is evident in every bite, making this shop a standout for purists.

5. Sal & Dom’s Pastry Shop – Bronx

This Bronx gem has earned a loyal following for its homemade cannolis. With their perfectly crunchy shells and creamy filling, Sal & Dom’s offers a no-frills, authentic cannoli experience that feels like a warm embrace from Nonna.

Unique Cannoli Creations

While tradition reigns supreme, NYC is also home to some innovative takes on cannolis. Many bakeries and pastry chefs are reimagining this classic dessert with creative twists, such as:

  • Chocolate-Dipped Shells: Adding a layer of rich chocolate for an extra indulgence.
  • Flavored Ricotta Fillings: Pistachio, espresso, and even Nutella-infused ricotta bring a modern flair to the classic.
  • Mini Cannoli Samplers: Perfect for those who want to try multiple flavors in one sitting.

These inventive creations strike a balance between honoring the cannoli’s roots and pushing its boundaries, giving dessert lovers even more to enjoy.

Cannoli Festivals and Events

NYC occasionally hosts events that celebrate this iconic treat. Keep an eye out for cannoli-eating contests or Italian food festivals like the annual San Gennaro Feast in Little Italy, where you can sample cannolis from multiple vendors. These gatherings are a fantastic way to immerse yourself in Italian-American culture while indulging in some of the best cannolis NYC has to offer.

DIY Cannoli

Inspired to try making your own cannolis at home? Here’s a simple recipe to get you started:

Basic Cannoli Recipe

  • Ingredients:

    • 12 premade cannoli shells (available at Italian specialty stores)
    • 2 cups ricotta cheese
    • 1/2 cup powdered sugar
    • 1 tsp vanilla extract
    • Optional garnishes: mini chocolate chips, chopped pistachios, or candied orange peel

  • Instructions:

    1. Drain ricotta overnight to remove excess moisture.
    2. In a bowl, mix ricotta, powdered sugar, and vanilla until smooth.
    3. Use a piping bag to fill the cannoli shells just before serving.
    4. Garnish with chocolate chips, pistachios, or candied fruit.

For fresh ingredients, visit NYC’s Italian markets like Eataly or Di Palo’s Fine Foods.

Conclusion

The search for the perfect cannoli is a delicious journey through NYC’s vibrant Italian neighborhoods and innovative bakeries. Whether you’re savoring a classic from Ferrara or sampling a Nutella-filled creation, the experience of enjoying a great cannoli is both nostalgic and joyful.

So, grab your “Keep Calm & Cannoli On” t-shirt, hit up these top cannoli spots, and indulge in the sweet taste of Sicily right here in the Big Apple.

What’s your favorite cannoli spot in NYC? Share your recommendations in the comments, and let us know which shop you think makes the best cannoli in the city! Don’t forget to follow us for more NYC foodie adventures and grab your “Keep Calm & Cannoli On” t-shirt to show off your love for this iconic dessert. Tag us in your cannoli adventures on Instagram @snackshacktees for a chance to be featured!

Back to blog